Table 1. Fresh weight, plant size (height, width) and color of two leafy vegetables according to cultivation type1),2)
| | | Batavia3) |
Hydroponically grown | Soil-grown |
| | | BAH1 | BAH2 | BAH3 | BAN |
Mean SD | Mean SD | Mean SD | Mean SD |
Fresh weight | | (g) | 133.31b±31.62 | 138.26b±4.92 | 127.15b±19.87 | 219.30a±53.98 |
(RSD%) | 23.72 | 3.56 | 15.63 | 24.61 |
Plant height | | (mm) | 186.25b±10.46 | 130.61d±8.54 | 152.33c±1.93 | 205.83a±12.79 |
(RSD%) | 5.62 | 6.54 | 1.27 | 6.21 |
Plant width | | (mm) | 84.89a±16.15 | 102.34a±4.59 | 88.62a±8.80 | 96.12a±12.11 |
(RSD%) | 19.02 | 4.49 | 9.93 | 12.60 |
Color | Outer leaves | (L*) | 48.36ab±2.89 | 54.24a±3.77 | 47.13b±3.46 | 52.05ab±4.58 |
(a*) | -11.14b±0.87 | -11.16b±0.50 | -9.47a±0.42 | -10.08ab±0.46 |
(b*) | 31.85a±5.88 | 33.51a±1.09 | 30.81a±0.08 | 29.35a±1.35 |
Middle leaves | (L*) | 56.30a±2.69 | 56.71a±4.33 | 59.98a±1.57 | 58.13a±1.00 |
(a*) | -11.47bc±0.94 | -10.91b±0.65 | -12.21c±0.33 | -8.30a±0.60 |
(b*) | 34.60b±1.34 | 32.05b±2.45 | 43.04a±0.63 | 25.83c±1.15 |
Inner leaves | (L*) | 59.24a±1.08 | 56.08ab±1.46 | 58.18b±0.82 | 57.98ab±1.31 |
(a*) | -8.39ab±0.93 | -10.11bc±0.78 | -10.91c±0.35 | -6.73a±1.47 |
(b*) | 28.82bc±3.56 | 29.30b±2.58 | 39.08a±0.82 | 21.38c±6.63 |
| | | Butterhead4) |
Hydroponically grown | Soil-grown |
| | | BUH1 | BUH2 | BUH3 | BUN |
Mean SD | Mean SD | Mean SD | Mean SD |
Fresh weight | | (g) | 127.66b±21.79 | 107.48b±8.59 | 108.09b±10.39 | 237.23a±109.00 |
(RSD%) | 17.07 | 7.99 | 9.61 | 45.94 |
Plant height | | (mm) | 138.94a±1.08 | 94.97b±5.21 | 94.46b±6.90 | 146.08a±24.69 |
(RSD%) | 0.78 | 5.48 | 7.30 | 16.90 |
Plant width | | (mm) | 98.47ab±10.93 | 100.38ab±3.86 | 93.52b±3.57 | 124.86a±25.92 |
(RSD%) | 11.10 | 3.84 | 3.82 | 20.76 |
Color | Outer leaves | (L*) | 43.48c±1.89 | 48.53b±1.85 | 49.49b±1.48 | 61.82a±1.79 |
(a*) | -11.64b±0.44 | -11.75b±0.45 | -10.90ab±0.31 | -9.75a±1.24 |
(b*) | 23.83c±2.56 | 29.67b±2.39 | 29.54b±0.22 | 34.34a±2.31 |
Middle leaves | (L*) | 60.41a±2.07 | 51.05b±3.77 | 43.37c±0.25 | 58.57a±0.68 |
(a*) | -10.99b±1.09 | -11.66b±0.63 | -10.68b±0.25 | -7.71a±2.14 |
(b*) | 33.91a±4.24 | 31.91ab±1.57 | 27.30b±1.12 | 33.48a±2.32 |
Innter leaves | (L*) | 65.91a±1.14 | 53.11c±2.84 | 41.18d±1.06 | 60.74b±3.59 |
(a*) | -8.23b±0.90 | -11.29c±0.11 | -10.55c±0.25 | -4.55a±0.85 |
(b*) | 31.36a±3.40 | 33.12a±0.92 | 27.05b±0.91 | 32.89a±1.94 |
Average of measurements (n=3)±standard deviation
Mean values with the same letter in a row are not significantly different at p<0.05.
Hydroponically grown batavia: BAH1 (farm A), BAH2 (farm B), BAH3 (farm C); butterhead: BUH1 (farm A), BUH2 (farm B), BUH3 (farm C)
Soil-grown batavia: BAN (farm D); butterhead: BUN (farm D).